For December 9, 2009   

  Print Report    Leave a comment  

 
Wednesday's Need-To-Know  

Smart / Dumb Money Confidence

 

* Markets remain trapped in a tight month-long trading range (no new news there).

 

* Short-term bearish inputs are moderating.

 

* The percentage of bears among newsletter writers declined yet again (2nd-lowest in 20 years).

 

* Those writers who are bullish, but looking for a short-term correction, have now shot up to the highest percentage since 1992.

 

* Three "C"s in the soft commodities complex are showing extremely high levels of bullishness.

 

 

The Dumb Money is 63% confident in a rally.

The Smart Money is 42% confident in a rally.

 

Smart/Dumb Confidence

View longer history

 

 

Short-term Outlook:  Neutral  As of Dec 4, 1115 SPX

 

 

Short-term Strategy

What:  We will remain neutral for now.

 

Why:  Usually, short-term trading within a range-bound market is easy (as much as we can ever say trading is "easy").  Simply sell approaches to the upper end and buy approaches to the lower end.  The past month hasn't been quite so accommodating, as equities have shown many "gap and then just sit there" days and strange, whippy intraday and overnight behavior.  That makes it hard to carry positions with any degree of confidence of not getting shaken out.  Currently, the S&P is sitting in the middle of its range between 1085 and 1100-1110 after bouncing near the lower edge yesterday.  Our shortest-term guides are mostly mixed now, though we still have those lingering trouble spots that we've discussed over the past week.  So we still have a modest bearish bias short-term, but unless the S&P violates and hold under 1085, we don't want to try to push any shorts in case we whip around yet again and test the upper boundary of this range.

 

Sentiment: 

Trend: 

Most of our short-term guides are neutral.

Still in the 1085 - 1110 range.

Support/Resistance: 

Other Tendencies:  to

Both support and resistance are relatively nearby (1085 and 1100).

We continue to have a few lingering bearish inputs that we discussed over the past week.

 

 

 

Intermediate-term Outlook:  Neutral  As of Apr 9, 843 SPX

 

 

Intermediate-term Strategy

What:  We will remain neutral for now.

 

Why:  In March, we discussed a large number of reasons to expect an imminent rally of one to three months' duration, or perhaps even more.  We've had ample opportunity to discuss the historic momentum since that low, and have seen little reason since to expect anything other than short-term corrections.  In late October, we looked at some "toppy" kinds of studies, and multiple failures to hold the 1100-1110 breakout area are another warning sign.  This is especially the case after we've seen a surge in speculative activity, which has continued during the first week of December.

 

Sentiment: 

Trend: 

Smart/Dumb Confidence Spread is neutral.

The S&P has a rising 200-day average and a series of higher highs/higher lows.

Support/Resistance: 

Other Tendencies: 

Resistance is still tough near 1110, but there are multiple layers of support under the major equity indexes.

Pullbacks after highs have been positive, but we've seen some "toppy" kind of behavior.

 

 

Equity Indicators - Updates and Extremes

 

Investor's Intelligence Bearish %

The big news in sentiment last week was the huge move in the percentage of newsletter writers who expect a market decline, which had shrunk to only 16.5% of the total.  Despite a market that really didn't go much of anywhere last week, bears dropped yet again, to 16.3%.  This ties the current reading for the 2nd-lowest in 20 years.

 

 

 

Investor's Intelligence Correction %

While newsletter writers are clearly "not bearish", they aren't exactly jumping up and down bullish, either.  The percentage who expect a market rally are only at 48.8%, which is about average historically.  However, there is a third group, and they are making just as remarkable an extreme.

 

Writers who generally expect the market to rise, but perhaps with a minor correction first, are more plentiful than they've been in 17 years.  The only weeks since 1992 that even come close to the current reading are 08/22/97, 06/29/07 and 05/29/09.  The writers were somewhat prescient in those cases, as the S&P 500 had difficulty maintaining any additional upside in the subsequent weeks.

 

 

  

Equity Market Indicators

 

Notes:

Corporate insiders, equity index futures positions (primarily in the Nasdaq 100) and the various sentiment surveys continue to be the more worrisome indicators among the broad groups that we follow.  Most of the others are either neutral or slightly bearish (for the market).

 

Among individual indicators, we continue to watch most closely for scenarios where 0% are bullish and 30% or more are bearish, which has been a very consistent predictor of imminent short-term weakness since March.

 

More history:   Short-term Score     Long-term Score    Indicators At Extremes

 

 

* New extreme

See all indicators

 

 

Bonds, Commodities and Currencies - Updates and Extremes

 

Public Opinion for Coffee, Cotton and Cocoa

Our latest Public Opinion data for commodities shows a high degree of bullishness among three "C"s in the softs complex.  Coffee, Cotton and Cocoa all have bull readings above 70%, and all are pushing up near the highest levels that we've seen over the past 18 years.

 

 

Following readings of 70% or higher, during the next month Coffee was up 43% of the time, Cotton was up 48% of the time and Cocoa was the worst performer, up 38% of the time.

 

It might be interesting to see which stocks in the S&P 500 did well (or not) in the month following similar extremes.  The table below highlights the top and bottom 5 most consistent performers following those extremes.  Many of them simply don't make any fundamental sense (i.e. why would KLAC do poorly when folks are extremely bullish about Coffee?) but a few of them do stick out (e.g. the railroads have done well when all three commodities have high bullish readings).

 

When Coffee Public Opinion > 70% (27 trades)

5 Best Performers 5 Worst Performers
Ticker Win % Ticker Win %
CMVT 90% KLAC 33%
XOM 85% MI 33%
APD 81% SLR 33%
CL 81% USB 35%
EMR 81% CHIR 37%

When Cotton Public Opinion > 70% (13 trades)

5 Best Performers 5 Worst Performers
Ticker Win % Ticker Win %
FDX 92% EP 8%
KO 85% BJS 15%
PSA 85% CMI 23%
SYK 85% CPWR 23%
AES 77% DTE 23%

When Cocoa Public Opinion > 70% (At least 15 trades)

5 Best Performers 5 Worst Performers
Ticker Win % Ticker Win %
DVN 81% AV 25%
SYK 81% Q 25%
NFB 80% CHIR 27%
NOV 77% MBI 31%
GIS 77% AMCC 32%

When All Three Public Opinions > 70%

(4 trades - 02/24/95, 9/19/07, 12/31/07, 02/20/08)

5 Best Performers 5 Worst Performers
Ticker Win % Ticker Win %
BNI 100% Q 0%
CSX 100% WLP 0%
HRB 100% CI 0%
CVS 100% ITT 0%
HAS 75% RAI 0%

 

 

 

 

Forwarding or other distribution of this email is prohibited without the express permission of Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  If you do not possess a firm-wide license, then forwarding this message will violate your subscription agreement.

 

VISIT THE SUBSCRIBER HOME PAGE

 

Privacy Policy      |      Disclaimer