Morning Report for Thursday, Mar 24, 2011
Previous Report    Print    Archive                                                 Posted 03/24/11 2:25 AM ET by Jason Goepfert

 

 

Top Stories In Sentiment

 

Smart / Dumb Money Confidence

 

There have been good reason to expect a re-test of the panic low from last week, but bulls managed to score another first-hour low which had been so common.

 

S&P 100 traders are apparently still looking for that correction, as the put/call ratio surged close to a five-year high yesterday.  Even during the past six months, such spikes in that ratio have led to more short-term weakness than strength.

 

The intermediate-term studies we've looked at over the past few days have been very bullish.  But the quick flip in the VIX index during the past week does not give quite the same level of conviction.

 

 

Risk Level:  4 (Moderate-Low)

 

The Smart Money is 50% confident in a rally.

The Dumb Money is 50% confident in a rally.

 

Smart/Dumb Confidence

 (click chart for larger version)

 

Top | Short-term Outlook | Intermediate-term OutlookChartsEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities

 

 

Short-term Outlook (1-5 Days)

 

 

Risk Level:  5

 

 

Summary:  The bulls managed to pull another one of their "gap down then first hour low" tricks that we had seen so many times prior to the recent correction.

 

The rebound was pretty impressive, and the pullback wasn't even enough to close the most recent 1% gap up from Monday morning.  We had looked at a couple of studies that suggested some short-term weakness was more likely than not, and that looked good for awhile, but a resumption of these first-hour low days is not a good sign for those looking for more downside.

 

One group of traders apparently doing so is those trading S&P 100 (OEX) options.  The put/call ratio for that index spiked to its highest level in nearly five years yesterday, on average volume.

 

Over the past six months, we've seen that ratio spike above 2.75 on nine other occasions, and during the next several days the S&P managed to gain a median of +0.4% at most, and suffered a median decline of -1.7% at worst.  So spikes in the ratio were decent signals that the risk/reward was titled more towards "risk" for the next few days.

 

My main reason for expecting additional short-term weakness was the fact that most panic lows tend to be re-tested during the next 1-3 weeks.  The spike in the OEX ratio helps support that idea somewhat, but yesterday's intraday reversal was impressive.  If we manage to climb above 1300 on the S&P 500, given the intermediate-term positives we've looked at, I would be hard-pressed to keep looking for that re-test.

 

Top | Short-term Outlook | Intermediate-term OutlookChartsEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities

 

 

Intermediate-term Outlook (1-3 Months)

 

 

Top | Short-term Outlook | Intermediate-term OutlookChartsEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities

 

 

Charts Of Interest

 

Study:  VIX And Its Deviation From 10-Day Avg

A big topic of interest has been the recent spate of volatility, including the "volatility of volatility".  There are any number of ways to monitor that, but what we do on the site is compare the VIX gauge of implied volatility to its 10-day moving average.

 

Generally, when the VIX is more than 10% below its 10-day average, then the stock market is overbought; when it's more than 10% above the average, it's oversold.

 

Over the past week, the VIX has gone from more than 30% above its average to more than 15% below.  That gives us precious few historical comparisons, but when we relax the parameters to 15% both ways, we get a few more.

 

The table below shows how the S&P 500 performed in the weeks and months following each instance.

 

 

The results were weak across the board, with extreme volatility in the results.  During the next week, the S&P was +/- 3% on 7 out of the 8 occurrences.

 

During the next three months, the median drawdown in the S&P 500 was -15.5%, compared to a median maximum gain of only +5.5%, so certainly a negative skew there.

 

This is in direct conflict with a couple of the studies we've looked at over the past couple of days.  How do we reconcile that?  It just depends on how much weight you want to give each one, but personally I think the others outweigh the negative connotations from this single study.

 

If we look at how the VIX itself performed, something curious shows up:

 

 

In the very short-term, the VIX tended to rise, which makes sense, since it tends to rise when stocks fall.  But three months later, the VIX was negative every time, even despite the poor performance in the S&P.

 

The takeaway is that very big spikes in the VIX very rarely persist for any length of time, even if stocks generally fall.  That's why almost all of the trading vehicles being designed around the VIX should be treated as trading vehicles only, and not "investments".

 

Top | Short-term Outlook | Intermediate-term OutlookChartsEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities

 

 

General Equity Market Indicators

 

Finally, the plurality of bearish (for the market) indicators that we had off and on since mid-December took its toll, as the S&P 500 faltered about 7% from its February highs and briefly turned negative on the year.  This isn't unusual, but it took a lot longer than it usually does when we have that many bearish indicators.  Now, for the first time since September we have more bullish than bearish indicators, though the former aren't yet quite high enough to be considered extreme (which is typically a good buy signal for the broader equity market).

 

More history:    Short-term Score      Long-term Score     Indicators At Extremes

 

Indicators At Extremes

 

 

 

Top | Short-term Outlook | Intermediate-term OutlookChartsEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities

 

 

Sector Sentiment

 

The pullback from the February highs hit some sectors harder than others, like usual, and the hardest hit in terms of overbought/oversold are Housing and Technology.  Utilities were also hit, due to the nature of the Japanese tragedy.  Most of the sectors have bounced since the 3/16 lows, and have a bit further to go before they would reach "maximum" oversold territory.

 

 

See sector breadth charts

 

 

Top | Short-term Outlook | Intermediate-term OutlookChartsEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities

 

 

Currency / Commodity Sentiment

 

Commodities in general have finally seen a moderate pullback, but it hasn't impacted the sentiment numbers too much just yet.  The "soft" commodities have seen sentiment shift the most, becoming more neutral after quite a while in "excessive optimism" territory.  The US Dollar and Natural Gas remain the most-hated among alternative assets.

 

 

See all currency/commodity indicators

 

 

Top | Short-term Outlook | Intermediate-term OutlookChartsEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities

 

Subscriber home page

 

NOTICE:  Forwarding or other distribution of this report is prohibited without the express permission of Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  If you do not possess a firm-wide license, then forwarding this message will violate your subscription agreement.

 

Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer

 

© 2001-2011 Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  All rights reserved.

sentimenTrader.com is a trademark of Sundial Capital Research, Inc.

Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  12527 Central Avenue NE, Suite 165  Blaine, MN  55434