Morning Report for Friday, August 5, 2011
Previous Report    Print    Archive                                                 Posted 08/05/11 2:00 AM ET by Jason Goepfert

 

 

Top Stories In Sentiment

 

Smart / Dumb Money Confidence

 

A once-every-few-years kind of a move like Thursday tends to trigger a large number of extremes, and we certainly got that.  When we have this kind of setup, the future is usually binary:  an all-out market crash, or a hard 2-3 day rally.

 

There are too many extremes to summarize here.  Mostly, though, what we're seeing is a stretch to nearly maximum levels in many price- and breadth-based indicators, which have only been seen a handful of times in the past 50 years.  Most of them point to a solidly higher market over the next 1-3 months.

 

 

Risk Level: 0 (Extremely Low)

 

The Smart Money is 71% confident in a rally.

The Dumb Money is 38% confident in a rally.

 

Smart/Dumb Confidence

 (click chart for larger version)

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Short-term Outlook (1-5 Days)

 

 

Risk Level:  2

 

 

Summary:  There's no shortage of extremes to mention after Thursday's carnage, and we go over a list of some of the more notable ones below, so I'm not going to re-hash them here.

 

Needless to say, many of our guides are stretched, some of them to what is for all practical purposes their maximum levels.

 

That doesn't, of course, mean that stocks can't continue to fall, but it does appear that we are now at a binary point in time - we will either crash harder (say another 5% - 10% over 1 or 2 days), or we rally hard for 2-3 days.

 

The most likely scenario, based on the kinds of extremes we're seeing and the magnitude of the price moves, is a 2 to 3 day relief rally, perhaps after an early dive lower and recovery on Friday.  Then we get a re-test of that panic low, and subsequently head higher for the next 1 to 3 months.

 

The monthly Nonfarm Payroll report is released early on Friday, so that could be a trigger either way.  Usually when we're so depressed heading into the Payroll report, we get a rally into the next couple of days (6 out of 7 times when the S&P was at a six-month low ahead of the report).

 

As for stepping in and buying this market, a less-risky way to do it is wait for some kind of capitulation and reversal, similar to what we saw on Wednesday.  A second such reversal would be highly unlikely to fail immediately.

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Intermediate-term Outlook (1-3 Months)

 

Risk Level:  0 

 

 

Summary:  On August 2nd, we highlighted some of the studies that had popped up recently, almost all of which have been pointing to higher prices on an intermediate-term time frame.

 

There were some that went contrary to that, such as the market's typical reaction following Apple's earnings report.  But those were few and far between.

 

On August 3rd and 4th, stocks slid lower and violated several important technical thresholds.  That raised the risk that we could be morphing into a more dangerous market environment, similar to what we saw in January 2008.

 

The selling pressure was so intense on August 4th, that it triggered a number of extremes that we have rarely seen, and most of them also point to higher prices on an intermediate-term (one to three month) time frame.

 

So we have a more dangerous technical environment, but also a very large number of indicators and studies suggesting just the opposite.  That's the main problem when trying to marry the two disciplines - technical analysis looks worse as stocks decline, while sentiment and other such measures look better.  The trick is determining when to value one more than the other.

 

Our "Risk Level" is at 0, which does *not* mean there is 0% risk in the market, only that the combination of a still-rising 200-day average on the S&P and large spread between our Smart and Dumb Money Confidence has led to the most positive future market performance out of any other combination.

 

We respect the ominous technical condition of the market, which means rushing in to buying into falling prices may not be the most wise choice.  If we do bottom somewhere around here, then there is typically a re-test during the next one or two weeks that creates a better buying opportunity for longer-term traders and investors, and that's the kind of opportunity to take advantage of the breadth and sentiment extremes that we'll be looking for.

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Charts & Studies

 

Studies:  Numerous 

 

There were a large number of notable developments on Thursday.  Instead of picking one or two charts, below we briefly go over everything that we got a question about or that popped up on our radar.

 


 

VIX Fear Gauge

 

The VIX "fear gauge" shot up 35% to a one-year high.  That has happened only two other times, both of which led to a gain in the S&P 500 of at least +8% at some point during the next three months.

 

10/19/87:  +10.9% return, -3.7% max loss, +16.4% max gain

10/13/89:  +1.0% return, -2.0% max loss,  +8.1% max gain

 

If the VIX gain was +25% or more, then the S&P rallied during the next three months 7 out of 9 times.  The two failures were doozies - right before the crashes in '87 and '08.

 


 

Up Issues Ratio

 

Thursday's single-day Up Issues Ratio was less than 5%, which occurred after the 10-day ratio was already oversold by being less than 40%.  Other than '46, all occurrences marked very good risk/reward scenarios on an intermediate-term time frame for the S&P.

 

Next three months:

 

5/21/40:  -1.6% max loss, +13.0% max gain

9/3/46:  -9.1% max loss, +3.0% max gain

4/14/47:  -3.0% max loss, +10.3% max gain

10/21/57:  -0.4% max loss, +6.6% max gain

10/19/87:  -3.7% max loss, +16.4% max gain

 


 

S&P One-Day Drop

 

The S&P dropped 4% in one day when it had been within 2% of a 52-week high sometime during the past month.

 

Next three months (since 1950):

 

6/26/50:  +7.2% return, -7.9% max loss,  +7.3% max gain

9/26/55:  +6.1% return, -4.3% max loss, +8.9% max gain

9/11/86:  +6.7% return, -3.0% max loss, +8.4% max gain

10/13/89:  +1.0% return, -2.0% max loss,  +8.1% max gain

10/27/97:  +11.5% return, -2.5% max loss, +12.5% max gain

4/14/00:  +11.4% return, -0.7% max loss, +11.9% max gain

 

All six occurrences showed a gain for the index, with a very positive risk/reward ratio.

 


 

Stock / Bond Ratio

 

Our Stock / Bond Ratio moved to -4 standard deviations.  This is nearly unprecedented in the 50 years of history that we have.  Here are the only other occurrences, and how the S&P performed during the next month:
 

10/19/87:  +8.1% return, -3.7% max loss, +15.3% max gain

8/31/98:  +6.2% return, -1.8% max loss, +8.2% max gain

10/12/00:  +2.7% return, -1.8% max loss, +8.2% max gain

 


 

Down / Up Volume Ratio

 

Down volume on the NYSE absolutely swamped up volume, by a factor of more than 90-to-1.  The instances below are the only other ones where the ratio was 90-to-1 or greater.

 

Next three months (since 1950):

 

6/29/50:  +11.4% return, -4.4% max loss, +11.5% max gain

12/4/50:  +15.1% return, 0.0% max loss, +16.8% max gain

6/9/53:  -0.1% return, -1.2% max loss, +5.3% max gain

9/26/55:  +6.1% return, -4.3% max loss, +8.9% max gain

10/19/87:  +10.9% return, -3.7% max loss, +16.4% max gain

10/26/87:  +9.6% return, -2.8% max loss, +15.0% max gain

10/27/97:  +11.5% return, -2.5% max loss, +12.5% max gain

2/27/07:  +8.5% return, -2.5% max loss, +9.5% max gain

6/4/10:  +2.4% return, -5.1% max loss, +6.2% max gain

 

Only one loser out of the 9 occurrences, and that was -0.1%.  The risk/reward was, once again, very skewed to the positive side.

 

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

General Equity Market Indicators

 

The mini-crash on August 3rd did wonders for pushing our indicators into extremes.  More than 30% of the indicators were in bullish (for the market) territory, the highest since near the low in June.  Historically, we have seen this measure rise to 50% or more, but anything over 30% can be considered extreme and traditionally a precursor to some kind of relief counter-move.

 

More history:    Short-term Score      Long-term Score     Indicators At Extremes

 

Indicators At Extremes

 

Bearish for equities  Bullish for equities 

 

NYSE Available Cash

Options Speculation Index

 

 

 

Rydex Bull/Bear RSI Spread

Rydex % of Sectors w/Assets > 50 Day Avg

Price Oscillator - S&P

Price Oscillator - NDX

Intraday Cumulative Tick - NYSE

Intraday Cumulative Tick - NASDAQ

Liquidity Premium - QQQ

TRIN - NYSE

TRIN - NASDAQ

Down Pressure - S&P

Down Pressure - NDX

VIX

VXN

Put/Call Ratio - Equity Options Only

Put/Call Ratio - Total of Moving Averages

Put/Call Ratio - OEX/Equity Spread

Put/Call Ratio - Total of All Options

Up Issues Ratio - NASDAQ

Up Volume Ratio - NYSE

Up Volume Ratio - NASDAQ

Stock/Bond Ratio

Put/Call Ratio - OEX Moving Averages

STEM Model

Composite Model

ISE Sentiment Index

VIX Transform

Fidelity Sector Breath

Up Issues Ratio - NYSE

Daily Cumulative Tick - NASDAQ

InsiderScore.com Buy/Sell Ratio

Sentiment Survey - AAII

OTC Volume

Smart Money Confidence

Dumb Money Confidence

Short-term Indicator Score

Intermediate-term Indicator Score

% Of Indicators At Bullish Extreme

 

* New extreme

See all equity indicators

 

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Sector Sentiment

 

The pullback at the end of July served to push most market sectors lower, with several into oversold territory.  The mini-crash on August 3rd shoved every sector into deep oversold territory, with not even the defensive sectors spared.  We can't recall another time in the past decade where all sectors were this far into oversold territory.

 

 

See sector breadth charts

 

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Currency / Commodity Sentiment

 

The Swiss Franc continues to be the safe haven currency of choice, and our indicators are reaching truly extreme optimism there.  The Yen isn't far behind.  Orange Juice has been in a steady trend for months, and traders have taken advantage, with our indicators about at maximum bullishness for the commodity.

 

 

See all currency/commodity indicators

 

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Member Comments

 

Please observe a proper level of civility when posting comments.  The point here is to foster intelligent discussions to help everyone learn.  Abusive posts will be deleted, at our sole discretion.

 

Comments powered by Disqus

 

 

 

Subscriber home page

 

 

NOTICE:  Forwarding or other distribution of this report is prohibited without the express permission of Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  If you do not possess a firm-wide license, then forwarding this message will violate your subscription agreement.

 

Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer

 

© 2001-2011 Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  All rights reserved.

sentimenTrader.com is a trademark of Sundial Capital Research, Inc.

Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  12527 Central Avenue NE, Suite 165  Blaine, MN  55434