Morning Report for Tuesday, September 13, 2011
Previous Report    Print    Archive                                                 Posted 09/13/11 3:00 AM ET by Jason Goepfert

 

 

Top Stories In Sentiment

 

Smart / Dumb Money Confidence

 

Stocks recovered well during the last hour of trading on Monday after an ugly morning, but those kinds of late-day reversals haven't been very reliable predictors of future strength.

 

This kind of early weakness and late strength has pushed the Smart Money Index up by more than 20% in the past two months, and out of its long-term trend.  While theory suggests that should be a good sign, historically it has not been, with the last two trendline breaks coinciding with the onset of bear markets.

 

 

Risk Level: 2 (Very Low)

 

The Smart Money is 54% confident in a rally.

The Dumb Money is 38% confident in a rally.

 

Smart/Dumb Confidence

 (click chart for larger version)

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Short-term Outlook (1-5 Days)

 

 

Risk Level:  5

 

 

Summary:  The new week started off on an ugly foot, with U.S. stocks following overseas markets lower, and drifting down even more as the day progressed.

 

Buyers stepped in during the last hour, igniting a furious rally in the closing hour.

 

It was an unusually strong late-day rally coming on the heels of what had been a poor day up to that point.  While it looks nice, these late-day rallies haven't been a great reversal sign.

 

Since 1998, there have been 9 other times that the S&P 500 SPDR (SPY) was down at least -1% then rallied at least +1% during the final hour to close up on the day.

 

By the end of the first half-hour the next day, SPY was positive only twice, and finished the next day higher also twice, averaging a return of -1.7%.  Even a week later, SPY was only positive 3 times, and averaged a return of -0.4%.

 

As we touched on last week, from a seasonal perspective this is buyers' best hope for at least a short-term reversal to stick.  After this week, the monthly pattern for September turns quite negative once again.

 

I'm still trying to catch up on the data we normally watch, but still can't see much of an edge here either way.  Yesterday's rally looks good, but as we saw above these late-day reversals haven't been very reliable indicators for bulls.  Our indicators remain mixed to neutral, and aren't much help here either.

 

NOTE:  For those wondering how my Ironman triathlon went this past weekend the short answer is...not good (again).

 

Similar to last year, the weather was extremely warm.  I'm large (6'7", 192 lbs) and throw off massive amounts of heat, so warm conditions are very difficult for me.

 

My swim was curiously slow, but the bike was fine.  I paid special attention to my hydration, and felt as though I made all the right decisions as the day progressed.

 

I started feeling "off" at about mile 4 of the marathon, and by mile 8 I was heaving.  I couldn't keep anything down, no matter what I tried, and I tried everything .  By mile 11, I started becoming extremely dizzy and ended up collapsing at 11.5.  A nurse came over, asked me a few questions, then said she was calling the medic and pulling the timing chip (meaning I was taken out of the race).

 

It turns out that I lost 21.5 lbs during the course of the day, and had extremely low blood pressure.  They hooked me up to an IV immediately and put in 3 liters of fluid.  I was feeling much better within 45 minutes and was wishing I could put my chip back on to finish the damn thing, but that's not the way things work.

 

I'm frustrated beyond belief and bitterly disappointed but I will, at some point, conquer that beast.

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Intermediate-term Outlook (1-3 Months)

 

Risk Level:  2 

 

 

Summary:  No change in outlook from Sept. 1st.

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Charts & Studies

 

Chart:  Smart Money Index

 

A couple of weeks ago, we discussed the Smart Money Index, which compares how the market trades during the first half-hour of trading versus the last hour.

 

The theory is that "dumb money" trades at the open while "smart money" trades during the final hour when most of the day's news has been released and acted upon.

 

Curiously, though, the Smart Money Index behaves opposite to what most believe should happen.  It tends to rise during bear markets and fall during bull markets.  That means the "dumb money" is in control during bull phases, while "smart money" is in control during bear phases.

 

It's a topic now because the SMI has broken definitively out of its long-term trend, and due to recent market activity (weakness in the morning, strength in the afternoon), it continues to rocket higher.

 

 

While short, sharp rises in the SMI can be good predictors of short-term lows in the market, large, extended increases in it have led to mostly negative longer-term market returns.

 

There have been 234 total days since 1998 when the SMI showed at least a 20% gain from its lowest point during the past two months.  Six months after those days, the S&P 500 showed a positive return only 26% of the time, and averaged a -3.8% return.

 

If we zoom out from the chart above, we can see the other two times that the SMI broke out of a multi-year downtrend, it did not bode well for stocks.

 

 

The chart is somewhat redundant, because the SMI tends to trend along with the market (though in an opposite direction), and breaks in the S&P 500's trendline tend to coincide pretty closely with that of the SMI.  But it's some confirmation that the recent "bull market" kind of activity of late-afternoon buying isn't necessarily cause for cheer among bulls.

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

General Equity Market Indicators

 

On August 8th, we registered so many extremes among our indicators that the percentage of those in bullish (for the market) territory very nearly reached 50%.  That is a level that has been rarely breached, especially lately.  The last time was November 20, 2008.  Stocks have traditionally done very well over the next 1-3 months when the percentage gets this high.

 

More history:    Short-term Score      Long-term Score     Indicators At Extremes

 

Indicators At Extremes

 

 

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Sector Sentiment

 

The pullback at the end of July served to push most market sectors lower, with several into oversold territory.  The mini-crash on August 3rd shoved every sector into deep oversold territory, with not even the defensive sectors spared.  We can't recall another time in the past decade where all sectors were this far into oversold territory.  Only the defensive Staples and Utilities sectors have been able to escape from deep oversold territory since then.

 

 

See sector breadth charts

 

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Currency / Commodity Sentiment

 

Public Opinion on many commodities turned quickly once we saw some selling pressure.  Contracts like Orange Juice and the Swiss Franc saw abrupt turn-arounds in Opinion, and are no longer showing extreme optimism.  Overall there aren't really any that are showing extreme pessimism, and the Yen is the most-loved among all the contracts.

 

 

See all currency/commodity indicators

 

 

Top | Short-term | Intermediate-termCharts & StudiesEquity IndicatorsSectors | Commodities | Comments

 

 

Member Comments

 

Please observe a proper level of civility when posting comments.  The point here is to foster intelligent discussions to help everyone learn.  Abusive posts will be deleted, at our sole discretion.

 

Comments powered by Disqus

 

 

 

Subscriber home page

 

 

NOTICE:  Forwarding or other distribution of this report is prohibited without the express permission of Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  If you do not possess a firm-wide license, then forwarding this message will violate your subscription agreement.

 

Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer

 

© 2001-2011 Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  All rights reserved.

sentimenTrader.com is a trademark of Sundial Capital Research, Inc.

Sundial Capital Research, Inc.  12527 Central Avenue NE, Suite 165  Blaine, MN  55434